How reviews work for me

I keep thing as simple as I can and grade on a five point scale.  
1=NO!! THIS IS TERRIBLE 
2=It's ok
3= Good
4=Great
5= AMAZING
so if am reviewing something that gets above a 3.5 it is really good but I give a verdict. which is basically my opinion with my experience.  

I make sections based on what I think needs to be talked about.  so like for a Musical Review I will rate it for the four things I find important, MUSIC, STORY, ACTING and STORY, I also add my OVERALL enjoyment of the show to the score and then show the total

These are the the main thing I will review I may do other things every now and then but these are my general topics

Movies:
STORY
ACTING
VISUALS
SCORE

Musicals:
MUSIC
ACTING
VISUALS
SCORE

Anime:
STORY
CHARACTERS
MUSIC/SOUNDS
VISUALS